Delivering Financial Transparency From The Ground Up

When it comes to determining true costs and accurate consumer usage for the new IT-as-a-Service model, there’s a lot more behind your business unit invoice than you think.

At EMC a team of business analysts has spent months conducting rigorous reviews of EMC’s IT data and then mapping and costing out every aspect of each ITaaS offering to make sure the new, financially transparent model is accurate.

As EMC IT makes the transition from working with a lump sum budget to charging back or showing back costs to individual business units for the IT services they consume each month, users can be confident that their usage is being carefully tracked and priced. After reviewing and remediating data gaps, we estimate that we are currently at 92 percent accuracy and climbing.

Getting to that level of quality data shouldn’t be underestimated, nor should the importance of such an achievement to the ITaaS transition. After all, each time a business unit consumes a service via ITaaS, IT needs to make sure the amount it is charged for that service reflects all of the costs to provide that service, from the more obvious infrastructure on which it runs to the labor supporting and other non-direct cost such as data center overhead.

Continue reading

Looking Beyond the Big in Big Data

Harnessing the power of Big Data is a lot like harnessing the power of the Web. It has the potential to revolutionize business decisions much like the Web did for everyday consumer choices.

Just think of the pain you used to go through when trying to decide which car or VCR to buy. If you were more diligent than I, you would search for consumer reports, news articles, reviews, and maybe check with friends and relatives before making a choice. But that required quite a bit of effort so, more than likely, you would base your decision on advertisements, maybe some comparison shopping and gut feel from making purchases like this in the past. Now you can get many times that amount of product information on the Web in an instant to guide your decision.

Big Data holds a similar promise for corporate decision-makers, including those at EMC. With the right tools and know-how, they will be able to go from using the standard 10 to 20 percent of data now at their disposal to using many times that amount. The vast amount of information contained in Big Data has tremendous potential for improving the quality of everything from marketing and sales forecasts, to product quality guidance to company security alerts.

Rather than information for choosing the best car, the corporate world will use Big Data to identify the next customer to call on or the next product innovation to pursue.

But what exactly is Big Data and does EMC have it?

Continue reading

Mapping a New Direction in IT Finance

Transitioning to an IT as a Service (ITaaS) model will have far-reaching effects on how IT Finance structures, analyzes and manages costs and resources. It will also open up new communications between IT Finance and controllers in individual business units to optimize EMC’s IT investments, shape new priorities and create new cost efficiencies.

ITaaS essentially requires that we shift from a centralized, cost-center-based budget to a service-cost-based, financially-transparent system. In other words, rather than using siloed categories, we need to reshuffle how we group and apportion IT costs around the ITaaS offerings and how they are consumed. In this way, we will be able to share with business units exactly what it costs to provide services, so they can make their own IT expenditure choices.

Under the traditional IT model, Finance administers a lump-sum budget for IT operations and oversees employee, capital and operating expenses by breaking them down into 60 to 70 separate cost centers based on function. For instance, costs for Telecom falls into one cost center; Help Desk falls into another; and Database another.

But this doesn’t work for charging each individual business unit for the IT services they consume because costs for providing an ITaaS service offering, such as email or TelePresence spans multiple cost centers, including Telecom, Help Desk, and Network.

Continue reading

Channeling Entrepreneurial Spirit to Launch ITaaS

Jon Peirce - VP of Global Infrastructure and Services and corporate sponsor for the EMC IT as a Service project

Changing IT from a traditional corporate IT organization to a professional service provider offering IT as a Service is a bit like making the ideological leap from communism to capitalism. The transformation encompasses everything from the changing IT processes and technologies to getting people to think and behave differently as they begin to deliver services instead of technology piece-parts.

Not only that, but this seismic shift has to be accomplished quickly with limited resources because every day we delay this transformation, more and more of our business clients turn to other sources to get their IT needs met, whether it’s public cloud service providers or standing up applications on servers underneath their desks.

While the work is not taking place in someone’s garage, here at EMC IT our ITaaS launch has all the markings of a start-up business venture—which is just the mindset I’ve encouraged my team to adopt as we move forward. Think like an entrepreneur. Act like a startup. Continue reading

Leading an IT Transformation

Reposted from Chuck’s blog entry on 10/25/2011:

Slide1Leading a transformational change in any large organization is not for the faint of heart.  

Even more so when the subject of said transformation is a large, entrenched IT organization delivering mission-critical services.  But that is exactly the situation so many IT leaders find themselves in these days.

At our recent IT Leadership council, Sanjay Mirchandani opened with an extended keynote detailing EMC’s IT transformation: the “why”, the “how” and the outcomes.  

This post is part of an extended sequence recapping all the excellent content at the event.  The back story and overview can be found here.

Why do I find this presentation particularly interesting?  

There are undoubtedly IT organizations out there that are arguably “better” than EMC’s own IT.  And I know for a fact that there is a large population of IT organizations that are still running in a tradtional legacy mode and have yet to begin their journey.

What’s fascinating to me about this story is the change: how a large IT organization went from one kind of IT organization to another.

Yes, EMC IT supports a large, global technology company, i.e. EMC itself.  And, yes, our situation and experiences might not be an exact match to your situation and experiences.

But, as I’ve shared the story over and over again, there is plenty to learn for many IT leaders who are looking for clear (and successful!) examples on how a large IT organization can fundamentally change how it does business.

To read the full blog, click here…

Organizing For Success

Reposted from Chuck’s blog entry on 10/26/2011:

Maybe I’m getting more cynical as my career progresses.  I’ve found I can take a quick look at just about any org chart, and quickly figure out how well the team is doing – or not — as the case might be.  

Most of the time, I’m pretty accurate.

Slide1The corollary is also true: if you want to deliver different results than you have in the past, you’re going to have to take a hard look at your organization: their mission, their structure, their skills — their very DNA.  

That’s what good leaders have to do to achieve results, I’ve found.

When it comes to IT transformation, the same is inevitably true — an organization produces what it’s organized to do.  

Organize around technology silos, and that’s what you’ll deliver.  Organize around large and complex projects, the same is true.  Ultimately, if you organize around delivering attractive and competitive IT services that your internal customers want to consume, and that’s what you’ll eventually deliver.  

And that’s exactly the mission that so many IT leaders are facing.

As part of our recent EMC IT Leadership Council, Jon Peirce delivered his experiences in leading just such an IT transformation.  Jon, as you might remember, is the key actor in many previous popular posts, such as “From Silos To Services“.  During this presentation, Jon laid out the key concepts and insights better than I’ve ever seen him do.

If you’re an IT leader, or aspire to be one, you’ll likely want to invest the time in reading this very lengthy and detailed post…

Achieving Financial Transparency

Reposted from Chuck’s blog entry on 10/26/2011:

You’re in the middle of a sequence of posts recapping the key thoughts and discussions resulting from EMC’s recent IT Leadership Council, the main theme being “IT Transformation”.

The background and context behind the event can be found here.  A more brief summary can be found here.

As a starting point, I wrote up Sanjay Mirchandani’s excellent foundational presentation “Leading an IT Transformation“.  Warning: it’s long, even by my verbose standards.

I folllowed that with a thorough recounting of Jon Peirce’s amazing presentation on “Organizing For Success“, which can be found here.  Warning: it’s even longer.

Presentation1During the event, we shared with the group that we were near completion of what we thought was groundbreaking work on a methodology for achieving financial transparency within the IT function.

Why is this important?  

At the end of the day, it all boils down to people and money as the big levers that IT leaders need to pull on.  Especially transformational IT leaders.  

Jon covered the people side at length.  I believe this white paper represents our best current thinking on how one goes about achieving financial transparency.

Any time there’s free market forces at work, intelligent choices tend to get made: what to invest in, how to measure returns, etc.  In many of our minds, financial transparency is the key enabler to achieving a virtual “free market” between internal IT services and the businesses that consume them.

Or, at least as close to one as we’re ever likely to get :)

Please — if you’re interested, take a moment to read this, and offer up your thoughts as to overall usefulness, how to improve, etc.  

We think it’s going to be a big discussion going forward.

How Transparent IT Financials Align Business and IT Goals

By Phil Gormley, CIO Office

“The true benefits of ITaaS come from better investment decisions, not demand management. While most CIOs plan to use IT service definitions to better manage investment priorities for business partners, they often find themselves trying to control demand. In fact, end-to-end IT services will not always reduce demand for IT offerings and may even increase it.”

–The Corporate Executive Board Company, July 2010

EMC IT—like many corporate IT operations— struggles with two conflicting client expectations. Year after year, the total cost of IT is held constant or reduced in the name of keeping overhead costs down. Meanwhile, business demands on IT keep growing and becoming more sophisticated.

For example, think about the tools available for collaboration today versus 10 years ago. With the evolution of multimedia conferencing, we can turn a telephone call into an interactive conference with tens, hundreds and even thousands of participants sharing ideas. And TelePresence lets colleagues around the world interact as if we are sitting at the same table without the time and cost of travel. These valuable, expensive new tools were in their infancy only 10 years ago.

While IT leaders near the breaking point from trying to do more with limited resources, the business units they serve have little recognition of the value of IT’s services. With no financial transparency, they only know a lump sum goes to undifferentiated IT. They don’t track the cost of the individual services they consume or even how much of each service they use.

Continue reading

What’s in your Wallet

Defining costs inspires IT conversations

By Neil Thibodeau, Director of Service Delivery for IT

Creating a financially transparent IT delivery system, in which business units can see—and potentially pay for—the amount of services they consume, isn’t just about costs. It’s about new conversations and choices.

In fact, showing back and charging back IT service costs is a crucial component to restructuring EMC IT operations to an IT as a Service model.

Up until now, business units at EMC had little break down of what they spend on IT services. The email services, desktops, collaborative tools and test environments used were, for the most part, funded through a non-specific IT budget. Even in cases where business units were aware of certain costs associated with certain applications they owned, they did not have visibility into the cost break down of such services. Expenses for things like labor, telecom, software, licensing, or depreciation were not included.

While that may have meant that business units didn’t have to concern themselves about the details of IT investments, it also meant that they often lacked control over their access to IT resources that could potentially benefit their operations. That access was indirectly limited by the CIO office, which in traditional fashion, sought to keep the IT budget from increasing. In turn, EMC IT was focused on meeting growing IT demands from business units with a limited budget rather than responding to the business’ needs.

Continue reading

Bringing Home Financial Transparency

With cloud computing and IT as a Service opening new doors, IT organizations are becoming more nimble in meeting the needs of the business units they serve by leveraging a more standardized, highly automated and agile infrastructure. This evolution provides an opportunity for IT to forge a new, more open dialogue with its business customers in determining how best to use these new capabilities.

Since IT as a Service is based on supply and demand, this new dialogue with the business needs to start with an emphasis on financial transparency. It is essential that the CIO and his or her team build a system that shows the true usage and cost breakdown of the IT services to be able to ‘showback’ and even chargeback the business for what they consume.

After all, continuing to operate IT services under a lump-sum budget without sharing expenses and options with the users is like running a household on a chunk of money without knowing what the individual bills cost. You can’t make informed choices about increasing your home’s energy efficiency if you have no sense of the monthly electric and heating bills. And how can you weigh the value you are getting from cable television, internet services, and cell phone contracts if those expenditures are melded with other utilities, trash pickup and snow plowing costs?

Continue reading